In a horizontal merger, one firm acquires another firm that produces and sells an identical or similar product in the same geographic area. Horizontal equity should apply to individuals considered. Part a provides a general introduction and overview of the main issues. The horizontal and vertical equity characteristics of the. Vertical integration and upstream horizontal mergers. Horizontal acquisition the acquisition of one company by another in the same or a similar industry. In so doing, we follow up on a few papers devoted to the relationships between the three concepts. Horizontal merger can be a a great solution for a company that struggles with a great number of competitors. Musgrave abstract to quote henry simons, the high priest of this paper reconsiders the proposition, he, it is generally agreed that taxes drawn from the pigovian tradition, that should bear similarly upon all people in vertical equity is the primary norm for tax similar circumstances simons, 19501.
Horizontal equity holds that taxpayers who have the same income should pay the same amount in taxes. Equity and equality iza institute of labor economics. A firm may also hope that such a merger may help in the development and marketing of new products. Horizontal equity financial definition of horizontal equity. Mrs thatchers theory was that since everyone had the same access to council services everyone should pay the same tax. Though a combination of vertical and horizontal equity through the tax code is a desirable goal, obtaining a clear definition and thus, application of horizontal equity has proven to be a tough task, based on the difficulties that arise when attempting to group individuals together based on equal access to resources and wealth. The driving principle behind vertical equity is the notion that those who. The bank merger of 1980s and the merger of hp and compaq are examples of horizontal merger. It is true that the analysis of nonhorizontal mergers in the guidelines has not been a. Horizontal equity is the idea behind the progressive tax system in place in many countries, though few countries implement it entirely. If similar businesses merge, the company expands its line of products or services and increases its power in the industry. The aim of a horizontal merger has a more direct path to the bottom line, helping a company to either increase market share or diversify its product offering and therefore its addressable market. The principle of horizontal equity is a basic yardstick used to gauge whether tax burdens are fairly distributed. Vertical mergers combine firms at different levels of production or distribution, whereas horizontal mergers combine firms at the same level.
Or does it stand in opposition to the advancement of human welfare. Horizontal merger a merger involving two or more firms in the same industry that are both at the same stage in the production cycle. Equity and equality is horizontal equity he the most widely accepted principle of equity. Horizontal and vertical equity linkedin slideshare. Department of economics, university of macedonia, 156 egnatia street, thessaloniki, greece, email address. Among taxrelated issues, one topic thats almost guaranteed to start an argument is that of the tax codes role in redistributing income. A horizontal merger decreases competition in the market. Guidelines on the assessment of nonhorizontal mergers under the council regulation on the control of concentrations between undertakings official journal c 265 of 18102008. This entry explores how horizontal equity interacts with consumption versus income taxation and implicit taxes.
Vertical equity is a method of collecting income tax in which the taxes paid increase with the amount of earned income. Horizontal inequity and vertical redistribution with indirect taxes core. Part b focuses on the economics of unilateral effects, while part c studies coordinated effects through the economics of tacit. Usually each member of the supply chain produces a different product or marketspecific service, and the products combine to satisfy a common need. Horizontal equity horizontal equity is based on the idea that those who have the same amount of wealth, or similar levels of income, should be taxed at the same rate as others within that same. The contribution of the merger guidelines to the analysis of nonhorizontal mergers frederick r. Treasurys merged file of 300,000 tax returns plus 22,000 non. Vertical merger legal definition of vertical merger. This is often a part of the market consolidation process, when too many companies exist. The poll tax is an example of a tax that has horizontal equity everyone pays a lump sum of. The horizontal dimension was present because both firms competed in the jet engines market. Quantifying the effects from horizontal mergers in.
The challenge followed decades of vertical and horizontal consolidation in telecoms, to the point where the sector now consists of an oligopoly of vertically integrated firms some of them operating across technologies, such as wireless and broadband. Guidelines on the assessment of nonhorizontal mergers. It typically occurs when there is an opportunity to acquire technology or to reduce contracting costs. Legislation notices and guidelines notices on substance nonhorizontal guidelines. Should those who have the ability to access more resources pay higher taxes than those who. As with horizontal integration, problems may be encountered with vertical integration also. Horizontal and vertical equity horizontal and vertical equity are two different concepts, but can work together in the same tax system with the aim of creating better equity overall. The contribution of the merger guidelines to the analysis. Introductory note theoretical concerns with horizontal merger have often been addressed to its welfare effects. Nonhorizontal merger guidelines originally issued as part of u. Vertical and horizontal redistributions from a carbon. A private equityled rollup is an example of a horizontal merger, whereby several companies that supply similar services or goods are combined under a common financial and reporting infrastructure to consolidate a fragmented industry. Vertical merger enforcement is less common than horizontal enforcement.
This paper argues that the case for the he principle is not as straightforward as is usually thought and that it. Horizontal mergers a horizontal merger, according to investopedia, occurs between firms that operate in the same space, as competition tends to be higher and the synergies and potential gains in market share are much greater for merging firms in such an industry. What is the difference between a horizontal merger and a vertical merger. It means that these two firms belong to the same industry but not to the same level of product development. Pdf the impact of vertical integration and horizontal. Vertical merger also helps companies cut losses and expenses because they merge with a complementary firm. A vertical merger can help secure access to important supplies and reduce overall costs by eliminating the need for finding suppliers, negotiating deals and paying full market prices. Salop vertical mergers can raise a variety of competitive concerns, including foreclosure, coordination, and misuse of sensitive competitive information. Aristotles formal theory of distributive justice makes the distinction between vertical and horizontal equity. Mergers, event studies and systematic risk abstract the combination of industrial organizational theory and financial data have been used to evaluate the economic effects of mergers. In microeconomics and management, vertical integration is an arrangement in which the supply chain of a company is owned by that company. Horizontal mergers occur when two businesses within the same industry and which produce the same kind of product join forces to reduce overhead while increasing profits. Court did not allow the mergerhorizontal merger and was unharmful.
The more contractual points that exist in the supply chain, the more expensive the end product may become. This type of merger eliminates competition between. Horizontal equity is based on the idea that those who have the same amount of wealth, or similar levels of income, should be taxed at the same rate as others within that same income bracket. The approach of the new horizontal merger guidelines the us department of justice and the federal trade commission released the 2010 horizontal merger guidelines on august 19, 2010. Horizontal and vertical equity definition economics help. It is contrasted with horizontal integration, wherein a company produces several items that are related to.
First, unlike horizontal mergers, vertical or conglomerate mergers do not entail the loss of direct competition between the merging firms in the. Agencies in 2006 remains a valuable supplement to these guidelines. Horizontal equity is an economic theory that states that individuals with similar income and assets should pay the same amount in taxes. Some observers are skeptical, comparing the acquisition to the. Horizontal merger is a merger between firms that are selling similar products in the same market. What does horizontal equity mean when tax discussions arise, one of the most frequent topics involves fairness and equitable taxes. Horizontal merger casescontinental can 1965 merging with hazel atlas glass jars.
Horizontal and vertical equity are two different concepts, but can work together in the same tax system with the aim of creating better equity overall. Pdf declining productivity and disappointing lack of profitability. Pdf vertical versus horizontal integration in the biopharma. Horizontal equity, vertical equity, and efficiency are the three central normative criteria. They usually bring out two fundamental issues, which are an increase in market power, by the reduction of the number of firms, and the possibility of efficiency gains. This paper presents a new concept the gini index of mobility that, together with the gini index of inequality, provides an overall consistent framework for the analysis of mobility, inequality, and horizontal equity. The managers of the merged firms may not be familiar with running, for instance, a market outlet. Horizontal equity is the equal treatment of equals, and this is a means of achieving a distribution of tax burdens that is vertically equitable. The commentary on the horizontal merger guidelines issued by the. Horizontal equity as an implicit appeal to vertical equity. A merger between two business firms that have a buyerseller relationship.
Horizontal equity is an important starting point for any tax system. In this regard, there are two primary types of equity distributions to consider. A vertical merger is when firms involved in different. A horizontal merger can increase a companys revenue by offering an additional range of products to existing customers. Department of justice and the federal trade commission horizontal merger guidelines issued april 2, 1992 and revised april 8, 1997. In a horizontal merger, a company purchases another business within the same industry value chain either a competitive or complementary business. Recent studies attempt to identify the economic sources of mergercreated gains by examining the stock market reaction of rival firms. Repertt over the past several years, professors richard musgrave and louis kaplow have engaged in an exchange over the question whether the concept of horizontal equity has any independent significance apart from vertical equity. A horizontal merger occurs when two or more firms that produce the same product join forces. Terms in this set 25 what are the types of mergers. Mergers legislation notices and guidelines notices. Horizontal equity is a principle that economists use to.
A theory stating that people in the same economic situation should pay the same taxes. Horizontal merger financial definition of horizontal merger. Horizontal equity can be consistent with also achieving vertical equity. A vertical merger is a merger between companies within the same supply chain. Potential competitive effects of vertical mergers scholarship. A horizontal merger is the merging of companies that operate in the same industry often competitors, creating economies of scale. Department of justice merger guidelines, june 14, 1984.
724 914 1000 831 924 1172 240 1392 510 238 284 215 700 31 751 859 1436 317 502 163 190 1217 1346 499 194 555 1419 655 1093